|
2010
PlotWatcher Time Lapse Camera Review
A couple months ago I started to hear the noise of a new camera coming
to market. This was a sneak release onto a number of
forums. I did a couple of PM’s and the result was an
eventual contact. I had explained our mission on the net
and that if they were interested we would do a review on
their product. We had many folks that we have contact
with that are not in the review business tell us that
they had already began to test this product. We had also
at that same time done a lot of research plus we had a
hoard of mail asking us to also look at the Garden
camera by Brinno which in one day I had my hands on one.
Once that review hit the net, we were notified that the
test unit from day6outdoors was finally shipped. Now we
are in a thither because we wanted to run both reviews
kind of parallel but we had several cameras slip in
between the two like units including another time lapse
camera by another manufacture.
The “PlotWatcher” is a time lapse stand alone camera that runs off 4 AA
cells and has chosen the thumb drive as the storage
device for the AVI’s that are collected. The
documentation that came with the unit did very little to
help with this review because there is no specification
page like found in all the camera instruction booklets
we normally deal with. The folks at day 6 asked me to
contact them by phone to get any questions asked for
this review. That would not be as if I were a regular
consumer and had only the book to work with and I was in
my truck setting at the gate of my hunting property
needing answers. We try our best to figure out with what
comes out of the box. Of course we can get it to operate
then measure the file size and play with it and figure
it out that way. This unit requires that you must have a
computer to properly set it up and insert the time date
information plus that is also the only method to view
what ever data that is collected. There is no TV out
like on the standard trail camera. We did not mention
this about the garden camera because it is designed for
back yard use and not field where we chose to take it
and play knowing its capabilities.
My choice of batteries was four pre tested Ray O Vac AA cells and one of
my Brinno thumb drives to start with. I installed the
software and the setup was very easy to do and I could
not see where most users would have difficulty with the
installation. I copied the mode and time/date to the
thumb drive and followed the instructions and inserted
it into the camera. One of the noticeable differences
between the garden cam and the plot watcher was the
garden cam came with batteries and a thumb drive and the
plot watcher did not. Now it is ready for operation. I
followed the turn on and turn off procedure according to
the booklet and there was a bit of confusion as to what
is on and what is off. The light sequence is the key
because the audible beep is so low that old ears would
have a hard time hearing it. I could very well see where
someone might think it was on and leave it in the field
only to return and find that he had actually turned the
camera off. Probably the best way would to just wait the
interval (start up) and see if the green light turns on
when it takes a picture and then you will know for sure
it is on.
The outward appearance of this camera is very pleasing with a nice fall
camo look. The big button is gray instead of orange
which helps it hide. There is a couple of little bungee
cords that come with it to hang it on a tree which is
not very secure and the first tree rat that happens
along would probably screw up the aim. The supplied
stake works well but lacks altitude if placed in the
ground. The stakes and bungee combination on the tree is
maybe a better way of mounting with the bungee cords
wrapped around the tree and stakes and the angle head
used to achieve aim. There is a much larger lens on this
camera that is the big different than the one seen on
the Garden camera. The garden camera lens is adjustable
from Macro to infinity but this lens is fixed. The black
plastic around the lens is semi matt so not to reflect
much light. The 1/4X20 tri pod insert on the bottom may
also be of great use for many of the after market items
we are hearing about to aid in mounting and security.
There is absolutely no security on this camera. Our drop
tests and leak tests all came out fine, but care must be
taken to insure that the latch on the battery door is
fully engaged. The first drop test dislodged the battery
cover and batteries because I failed to get it to snap
closed. Besides the custom method of setting the
operating parameters there is a wheel between the
batteries to select six non custom settings. Which
either gives you an operating interval with no time out
to an operating interval with a mid day time out to
conserve battery life during non peak periods. This old
hunter learned a long time ago that the non peak hours
is when I have had my greatest success at much larger
and older bucks. The wheel selection starts at day break
and will take pictures for four hours then go to rest if
selected either 4 or 8 hours depending on where you have
the wheel set. It looks like they have taken the very
acceptable Garden cam and made it a little more hunter
friendly. We will get this on the hill in a few days and
see how it works and log some of the differences in
function between this and other TLV cams we have in the
system.
I have got my feet wet with a couple of other time lapse cameras
(dedicated) plus we have ran tests using some of those
trail cameras that also can be programmed to do this
task. The results were all very positive but because we
seen no interest generated we decided to not test that
capability on recently released cameras. The hype
generated on the forums spiked a degree of interest in
ways to make time lapse fit more into the hunting
vocabulary. This product along with its little brother
has chosen to use the flash (thumb) drives as storage.
This will add about forty dollars the cost (two drives)
and require that you have an available USB port on your
computer to view the pictures and do the setup. Most
enthusiasts who use trail cameras have a supply of SD
cards which has pretty well become the standard.
The
Game Finder software (included) is a big plus for this
device. It was easy to install and during my initial
tests was a big plus over the Brinno Garden cams
version. It is a toss up though with the Wingscapes
because of the entire extra features available there.
The stop/reverse and zoom is really handy to use. We
will get much further into this once we get this cam on
the hill. So far it looks like it will do a pretty good
job, except we found initially that when zoomed (using
the included software) even on close targets the
pictures were somewhat grainy. I went ahead and
purchased more 8 gig thumb drives (about $20 each) so we
could go ahead an swap out the drives instead of having
to bring the whole camera back and check the results.
Carrying lap tops to the field along with the mass
amount of other equipment is a pain and it is much
easier to just swap cards and be done with it. That way
the only other thing we have with us is for battery
support. Well as soon as a hole on the hill opens up we
will start the field tests.
06-01-2010 update: We managed to set up and
do an initial trial to measure advertised function.
First off their software is much handier to use than the
other cams tested. The zoom feature is good but a
distant spec becomes even less when zoomed. Horn count
is limited to distances under a hundred feet. As far as
entrance and exit to a distant given area it will tell
you that information, but only that information and not
gender. The firmware monitoring of light conditions
appears to be an area where there is some more work to
do. We could see as much as two hours difference on some
days when the camera would start and shut down. The
camera is weather resistant with the acceptance of water
on the lens. Rainy or drizzle conditions wipes out
intelligible video content. This cam is most definitely
a candidate for a roof to keep the moisture off the
lens. Not having a standard day/night sensor is a plus
so the roof should not effect operation.
Software is easy to use but the motion would detect
sunlight moving and the threshold had to be increased to
avoid this. The zoom is a great feature but is limited
because of graininess. A custom area of motion detection
(rectangle) can eliminate blowing tree tops
stopping the video unnaturally as "motion". One day’s video is
stored per file, and stored in files ending in .TLV
which can be changed to .avi and windows media player
played them just fine. You can stop the video and step
frame to any image then export that image for archiving
or Emailing. You can save small portions of video in
original quality or save as a windows media video in a
compressed format for Emailing and so on.
The indicator lights give a better indication of the
on/off status that the garden cam. There must be a
programmed write time to the drive that is not during
the delay period. There was very good activity in front
of the camera up until 1
PM, at which time we swapped the drive. The
last picture on that drive was at
10:30 telling us that those pictures taken
during the 2.5 hours from
10:30
to 1 were lost. There are several upgrades that Anthony
picked out that he would like to see happen but this
will be handled when he does the write up on the
software being he is our resident programmer and is
really into the audio and video areas.
So far we will say that we feel the camera works as
advertised with the exception of the zoom feature in the
software works but the value is more toward much closer
targets and not that 60 to 70 yard animal. We like most
everything so far because of its function, but we bumped
into some areas where things left us wanting. The extra
dollars for this camera over the other two we just
tested show up in a somewhat better picture quality and
some fun to use software for your presentation. We have
a lot more to look at and this is just day one in
the process.
Those who have nice open woods and fields/plots where
the trees are not too thick will probably get more value
out of this kind of camera. The animals moving through
the trees were very hard to see unless they were hitting
little patches of sun. Only those animals that managed
to get much closer were picked up and noticed. The start
and stop times were very good for maybe the light needed
for photography but was an hour inside both dawn and
dusk for the prime movement times so those animals would
not be recorded. The slightest intrusive activity to the
animal’s domain will in most cases alter travel routes
and travel times more toward nocturnal activity. This
style of camera would be a good tool until the animals
get wise or have been somewhat disturbed then you will
see the same thing that we see with trail cameras, those
are 90% nocturnal (buck/doe fawn) pictures and 10%
(doe/fawn) day pictures. The comfort zone moves toward
darkness as stress to an area is increased. Off season
time lapse pictures will probably help to curb that itch
from the addiction that you may have developed by years
of trail camera abuse. All of us will probably find a
use for this tool but it will probably be directed more
towards what it finds during the day time and not
towards it being a scouting tool early to mid season.
This camera could very easily watch a hunt camp or boat
dock for visitors as long as you set up relatively
close. There is no flash or PIR sensor so everything on
the camera could be covered up to hide it except the
lens and it needs a little roof. If you choose to use it
for security, be sure to put a little black electrical
tape over the three indicators or they may give the
cameras location away.
The area we call “the hill” is one of our testing areas
and we keep underbrush cleaned out so we have some areas
where we can look through the woods to a hundred yards.
The trees are not thick (see video) but even under these
conditions, movement at a hundred and fifty feet would
be difficult to determine what it was until it was
somewhat closer. I studied one video a step at a time
and believe me the animal got real close before I was
sure what it was. This dappled sunlit environment is
common here in the southeast but many areas have much more underbrush. Our
food plots have grown up from disuse.
06-05-2010 update: We still have this
camera on the hill waiting for its batteries to run
down. We will check today and when they do we will
record the time and the amount of days it recorded at
the setting we have chosen. Next it will get moved to
our other area and put on an big area to watch.
06-08-2010 update: Now that we have had a
degree of time on this camera and the Brinno camera
(PWC), we have a few things to talk about. We have not
analyzed the exact battery life because we think there
is either a fault with the firm ware or there is a bug
in the camera. It is suppose to take a picture and
analyze the light in the picture to say is there enough
light to keep on working or not (It does not have a
light sensor). Most of the time, the morning start times
have been around the same time but the stop time may
vary as much as 6 to 8 hours on one or two days during
the life of a set of batteries. Anyway we did not
experience this on the PWC Brinno during the testing and
it started and stopped very well. This light monitoring
through software seems to be not nearly as effective as
the light sensors on the standard trail camera. Another
troubling thing is after it does shut down at night the
indicator will continue to flash all night which might
shorten battery life somewhat plus be a dead location
giveaway to anyone in the area after dark.
Let’s talk about its function a little. The picture
quality of this camera is better than what we
experienced with the other two that are now in the
system. Even at that we feel that if its goal in life is
to locate travel routes/times, Exit/entrance points, and
general activity it does a good job of this during the
day light hours. To use this to analyze a particular
animal as to horn count or age would be weak unless that
animal was very close (<40ft). At the distant end of a
food plot entrance, the animals would be just dark specs
that are moving but this information would give you
points of travel. Hopefully we will produce a video of
that type of setup very soon because the next set up
will be exactly that.
06-15-2010 update: Made a special trip to
check on this camera and the fellow that was supposed to
install it on his new food plot has a situation. It
seems that on the way to the field he passed the new ATV
store and they had all their wares displayed out front.
Well being the sportsman that he is he was paying a lot
of attention to a certain ATV that was displayed high on
a perch. What he wasn’t looking for was the car that had
stopped in front of him. The truth is we had a slight
delay but the cam did make it to the field and is in the
process getting pictures. We will probably have the
results in 5 or 6 days provided I can keep the blinders
on him when he takes that route again. Sorry for the
delay.
06-22-2010 update: My friend did not state
whether or not he got presented with a pink slip for his
misfortune while checking out the perched ATV. He did
though manage to get the camera deployed on a nice open
food plot. The set up was looking down a long fence line
with a horse pasture to the right and a big open plot to
the left. For the time spent we saw very little
activity. There were some hawks that perched on the
fence posts and now and then one of the horses would
stretch over the wire to grab a bite of the food from
the forbidden zone. However we did have one crusty old
doe that romped around a little and showed us her
entrance and exit routes. We will get a little flick put
together and show her playing in the plot. We thought we
had selected the full day on the camera but for some
reason it reverted to the morning and evening program.
This was not a problem for us gathering footage except
the camera worked great during the morning and when it
shifted to evening the pictures became extremely fuzzy
instantly. That setting just did not seem to work for us
and we are going to re program to insure it stays going
all day to avoid this issue. We will show examples of
this change from morning to evening and the loss of
picture clarity. This very hot near 100 days really
limit the amount of deer activity during the day time.
Other than bird activity there was just not very much
daytime activity with the rabbits, coon, fox, coyote, or
cats. The tree rats even kept to the shade and did not
want to venture out in the high heat. We may try a
little later and use a combination of day camera and
evening trail camera operations and see just what is
there.

06-22-2010
#2 update: I failed to mention that the little
clear plastic rain hood worked great and kept the rain
from collection on the lens. We have had some very
strong afternoon storms and other than the supplied
stake looking like it was made out of dirt there was no
ill effects from the rain once this simple hood was
installed.
06-25-2010 update: We are getting ready to
do another setup on a big open field where we have some
fair traffic that moves between two heavy wooded areas.
This time we will not select the dead during the day
option due to the wake up being quite fuzzy. This should
be an interesting setup and is the home of one very
large critter that takes on a moose look during the
velvet period. We are hoping to capture him making his
way between the old water hole and the bedding area. The
other two TL cameras will probably be keeping this cam
company in this same area.
07-03-2010 update: The best laid plans get
slammed by mother nature. Limbs down and the stake
knocked over so the result is a lot of pictures of the
sky and dead batteries. Maybe next week.
07-27-2010 update:
Another couple of weeks and have had a steady flow of
field reports and most really love this camera and the
software. What is not liked is the 4 day battery life
unless you turn it down to just a few pictures. The most
we have heard is “this camera does what it is supposed
to do but does not match the advertized battery life”.
This is our findings also and if they were to engineer a
method of hooking up an external battery then it would
be much better. Day only during the off season does give
the users an idea of movement. Once a little pressure is
felt the habits change and that gathered data would be
of little value except for the first few days of the
season. We are going to close this review at this time
and wait for a period later in the year near the season
to do a re visit.
10-24-2010 update:
This unit has been pulled out of the closet along with
several other time lapse cameras, three of which were
mated up against this camera at the beginning. The
outdoor forums were busy with the shill process
throughout the past three months pushing and promoting
this product. This was a turn off to many but because of
the amount of issues reported from the field everything
probably balanced itself out. There was a software
upgrade and we performed this which is supposed to
improve the four day battery life to a little longer. We
will see if there is any change during this go around.
It is back out deployed as of this morning and in a
couple weeks we will have another update.
11-05-2010 Update:
After applying the firmware update and deploying in the
field, we returned after 3 weeks to get the camera.
Inspection of the thumb drive showed that the camera
operated 4 hours per day from 10-24-2010 through
11-04-2010. This is a full 12 days of operation
and 48 hours of filming coverage at 10s intervals.
This is vast improvement on battery life. Picture
quality appears to also have been improved. We are
now closing this review.
|
Original
Quality 50 Frame Sample
Note: This file is 8MB (fairly large)
Midmorning Dappled Sunlight Sample
 |
|
The videos
below are 100 frame exported videos using the
Windows Media format feature in the software.
I have left them in the exported format so you
can see exactly what they will look like using
the software
Horses on Fence #1
Horses on Fence #2
Deer at 100 yards
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|